Loading...
Question 205 of 378

A Security Council resolution requires the concurrence of

  • A. 1 of the 5 permanent members
  • B. all of the 5 permanent members
  • C. 9 of the 15 council members
  • D. 3 of the 5 permanent members

Correct Answer: B

Explanation
The correct option is B. all of the 5 permanent members. Detailed Explanation:
  1. Understanding the Security Council Structure:
  2. The United Nations Security Council (UNSC) is composed of 15 members: 5 permanent members (P5) and 10 non-permanent members.
  3. The P5 consists of the United States, the United Kingdom, France, Russia, and China. These countries hold significant power within the Council.
  4. Voting Requirements for Resolutions:
  5. For a resolution to be adopted by the Security Council, it must receive a minimum of 9 votes in favor out of the 15 total members.
  6. However, there is a crucial stipulation regarding the P5: if any one of the permanent members votes against a resolution (a veto), the resolution cannot be passed, regardless of the number of votes in favor from the other members.
  7. Why Option B is Correct:
  8. The requirement for "all of the 5 permanent members" to concur means that if even one of them votes against the resolution, it will not pass. This is known as the veto power.
  9. Therefore, for a resolution to be adopted, it must not only achieve the majority of votes (9 out of 15) but also avoid any vetoes from the P5.
Why the Other Options are Incorrect:
  • Option A: 1 of the 5 permanent members:
  • This option is incorrect because it suggests that only one permanent member's approval is needed for a resolution to pass. In reality, any one of the P5 can veto a resolution, which means that their collective agreement is necessary to avoid a veto.
  • Option C: 9 of the 15 council members:
  • While it is true that a resolution needs 9 votes to pass, this option fails to account for the veto power of the P5. If any of the P5 members vote against it, the resolution will not be adopted, regardless of the 9 votes in favor.
  • Option D: 3 of the 5 permanent members:
  • This option is also incorrect because it implies that only a minority of the P5 can approve a resolution. In fact, all P5 members must either support the resolution or abstain for it to pass without a veto.
Summary of Key Points:
  • The UN Security Council consists of 15 members, including 5 permanent members with veto power.
  • A resolution requires at least 9 votes in favor but must also avoid any vetoes from the P5.
  • The veto power means that all 5 permanent members must concur for a resolution to be adopted.
  • Understanding the voting dynamics of the UNSC is crucial for grasping how international decisions are made.
This comprehensive understanding of the voting process in the UN Security Council is essential for anyone studying government and international relations, especially in the context of global governance and diplomacy.
← Previous Next →
Jump to: 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214